Comet Tsuchinshan-ATLAS may be one to watch for at dawn late next month.
If predictions and prognostications hold true, a decent comet could grace dawn skies in late September into early October. We’re talking about Comet C/2023 A3 Tsuchinshan-ATLAS, discovered early last year. Early signs suggest it could be the best comet of 2024… if it survives until perihelion.
The comet was discovered jointly by the Tsuchinshan (Purple Mountain) observatory in China and the ATLAS (Asteroid Terrestrial-impact Last Alert System) sky survey on January 9th, 2023. Later ‘pre-discovery’ images date back to 2022. The comet was discovered 7.2 Astronomical Units (AU) out in the outer solar system, beyond the orbit of Jupiter. This always a good sign in terms of how the comet will behave on approach.
The orbit of Comet Tsuchinshan-ATLAS. Credit: NASA/JPL.Early estimates put the orbital period for the comet at 80,000 years. Later refinements on the orbit now puts it at millions of years, possibly due for ejection post perihelion. This means that C/2023 A3 Tsuchinshan-ATLAS is likely a first-time visitor from the Oort Cloud, and should be dynamically new. This another plus and always a good thing in terms of activity.
The path of the comet seems to hang stationary in the constellation Sextans through September, as it is headed towards us as seen from our vantage point in space. The comet is on a high 139º inclination retrograde orbit about the Sun. Perihelion 0.39 AU from the Sun interior to the orbital aphelion distance of Mercury occurs on September 27th, and the closest Earth approach for the comet occurs on October 12th, at 0.472 AU (70.6 million kilometers) distant.
Southern hemisphere observers may get a short look at the comet starting in mid-September. The best show for folks up north begins in the last week of September into the first week of October, when the comet sits about 10 degrees above the eastern horizon in the dawn. The slim waning crescent Moon will pair with the comet on the mornings of September 30th and October 1st.
Looking to the southwest on the morning of October 1st. Credit: Starry Night.Said Moon is headed towards an annular solar eclipse on October 2nd. Lucky observers along the path crossing the southern tip of South America might just see the comet along with Venus during annular phases, if (a big ‘if’ to be sure) it exceeds expectations and reaches negative magnitudes.
The comet versus the October 2nd annular eclipse. Credit: Starry Night.We’ll also get a look at Comet Tsuchinshan-ATLAS courtesy of the joint solar observing SOHO mission, as it transits the LASCO C3 field of view from October 7th to the 10th. From there, the comet will transition to the evening sky in late October, as it fades back down into binocular visibility range and heads back out of the solar system, perhaps to never return again.
The comet versus SOHO’s LASCO C3 imager. Credit: Starry Night. It has been a roller coaster ride for the comet in 2024. How bright will Comet Tsuchinshan-ATLAS be at perihelion? The comet seemed to be under-performing in terms of brightness in early 2024, suggesting a breakup and a ‘fizzle’ could be imminent. As of writing this, the comet is back up on the expected light curve at magnitude +8. Comets often neglect to read predictions, and can fail to measure up to expectations… we all remember ISON in 2013. On the plus side, remember F3 NEOWISE in 2020, which actually exceeded anticipations? One factor will aid the visibility of comet Tsuchinshan-ATLAS right around Earth approach: its brightness may be helped a bit by an effect known as forward scattering. And of course, all bets are off in terms of brightness in the event of a well-placed outburst.
“A3 (Tsuchinshan-ATLAS) is now sort of on the brightening line to get mostly as bright like predicted, although my own projection shows it peaking more like magnitude +4 to +5 because the trend line is a bit south of the optimum line…” astrophotographer Eliot Herman told Universe Today. “So it will not be (naked eye) visible at brightest, but…it will be a fine telescopic comet (or ‘camera comet’) kind of like P1 Nishimura. That is what I am thinking unless it shatters or splits. I think it is going to fall short of imagination, which is about the norm for comets.”
Here’s a Month-by-Month look at Comet Tsuchinshan-ATLAS:
7-Flips over to the dawn sky
27-Reaches perihelion
28-Crosses into the constellation Leo
The projected and observed (black dots) light curve for Comet Tsuchinshan-ATLAS. Credit: Seiichi Yoshida’s Weekly Information About Bright Comets. 1-The waning crescent Moon sits 11º from the comet
2-The Comet is 18º from the Sun during an annular solar eclipse
4-Crosses into the constellation Virgo
7-Crosses into SOHO’s LASCO C3 field of view
8-Crosses the ecliptic plane northward
9-Passes 3º from the Sun
10-Exits SOHO’s LASCO C3 field of view
11-Flips over to the dusk sky
12-Passes closest to the Earth
14-Crosses the celestial equator northward, and makes an edge-on, orbital plane crossing
15-Photo-Op: Passes 1º from +9th magnitude Comet 13 Olbers
15-Crosses into the constellation Serpens Caput
16-Passes just over 1º from the globular cluster Messier 5
19-Crosses into the constellation Ophiuchus
20-Passes near the +3.8 magnitude star Lambda Ophiuchi (Marfik)
29-Passes between the +3rd magnitude stars Cebalrai and Gamma Ophiuchi
1- Passes near the +3.9 magnitude star 67 Ophiuchi
10-Passes into the constellation Serpens Cauda
20-Passes very near (occults) the +4.6 magnitude star Alya
25-Passes into the constellation Aquila
26-Crosses the Celestial Equator southward
In December into early 2025, the comet drops back below +10th magnitude.
Comet A3 Tsuchinshan-ATLAS from July 25th. Image credit: Eliot Herman.Keep in mind, like deep-sky targets, all of that precious quoted magnitude for a comet is ‘smeared out’ over an apparent surface area. We usually think of the naked eye cutoff for stars under a good dark sky is +6, but a comet generally won’t reach naked eye visibility until about +3 magnitude or so. This is also usually the point at which a given comet becomes bright enough to capture along with foreground objects, always a photogenic sight.
Good luck and clear skies on your quest to see comet Tsuchinshan-ATLAS, on what is very probably its one-time only visit to the inner solar system.
